tech consumer guide

tech consumer guide

Last updated on September 1st, 2020 at 03:41 pm

Alienware M15/17 Vs Apple MacBook Pro [2020 Comparison]

Get It Fast. Join To Get The Best Deals

Be on top of the latest deals and offers

Last updated on September 30th, 2020 at 03:49 pm

In this article, we compare the Alienware M15/17 to the Apple Macbook Pro. Here’s everything you need to know about Dell Alienware Vs MacBook Pro.

Overview

 
Alienware M15/17
Apple Macbook Pro
Design (5)
4
4
Build Quality (5)
3
5
Upgradeability (5)
2
1
Display (5)
5
5
Thermals (5)
3
1
Performance (5)
4
3
Battery Life (5)
3
5
Total (35)
24
24

Alienware M15/17 – Pros & Cons

Alienware New M15 Gaming Laptop, 15.6' 144hz FHD Display, Intel Core i7-9750H, NVIDIA RTX 2060 6GB, 512GB SSD, 16GB RAM, AWYA15-7947BLK-PUS

Pros

Excellent Performance

Beautiful Display & Design

Slim & Lightweight

Decent Battery Life For A Gaming Laptop

Cons

Soldered RAM And WLAN Card

Flipped Motherboard

Runs Hot

Apple MacBook Pro – Pros & Cons

New Apple MacBook Pro (16-inch, 16GB RAM, 512GB Storage, 2.6GHz Intel Core i7) - Space Gray

Pros

Excellent Performance

Solid Build Quality

Beautiful Display

Slim & Lightweight

Long Battery Life

Cons

Can’t Be Upgraded & Difficult To Repair

Still Uses Butterfly Keyboard

Runs Hot, Thermal & Power Throttles A Lot Limiting Performance

Design, Build Quality And Upgradeability

Dell redesigned the Alienware and the result was a beautiful gaming laptop. The new Alienware takes it looks from the Alienware Area-51m. You could say it is a slim and lightweight version of it. It weighs 4.75 lbs (2.16 kg) and it’s less than an inch thick. You can easily carry this around.

Sale
New Alienware m15 15.6 inch FHD Gaming Laptop (Lunar Light) Intel Core i7-10750H 10th Gen, 16GB DDR4 RAM, 1TB SSD, Nvidia Geforce RTX 2070 Super 8GB GDDR6, Windows 10 Home (AWm15-7418WHT-PUS)
  • High-end materials like magnesium alloy, copper and steel provide a premium, lightweight and performance-driven gaming experience with...
  • Our fastest panel yet offers 300Hz 300nits 3ms Full HD for smooth, high-speed motion graphics
  • Alienware Cryo-Tech optimizes component cooling, which maximizes overall performance and keeps your laptop cool to the touch
  • FHD display with 3ms response time, 100,000:1 contrast ratio, 60Hz refresh rate and 300-nit brightness for pulse-racing gameplay
  • At just 4.65lb and under 20.5mm, the new Alienware m15 is the thinnest laptop in Alienware history—even lighter and leaner than our...

Last update on 2020-09-30 at 20:35 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

The gaming laptop comes in two colours – lunar light (white) and the dark side of the moon (greyish black). The rear vents are covered by RGB LED strips and protrude out of the laptop. Giving it an alien spaceship look.

Majority of the ports are also found at the back including the Thunderbolt port. The vents on the rear, underside and keyboard deck take the shape of honeycombs. Whiles the ones on the side are slanted.

The Alienware logo on the back is also RGB. Overall, the design is beautiful and looks a lot different compared to a lot of gaming laptops. The build quality of the Alienware though could have been better.

Alienware M17 Review

Made from plastic and magnesium alloy. It has quite a bit of flex. The lid and keyboard deck are magnesium alloy whilst the rest is plastic. At this price point, Dell could have done better. Still, it is quite sturdy and not something to lose sleep for.

However, upgradeability is disappointing. It is easy to open the laptop. But, once in you quickly notice the motherboard is flipped, RAM and WLAN card are soldered and there is no HDD bay. The only upgradeable component there is the SSD storage.

You can’t upgrade the RAM and WLAN card. If you get the 16GB model, you are stuck with it. Fortunately, the previous Alienware model doesn’t have a flipped motherboard and you can also upgrade the RAM.

Apple has maintained the MacBook Pro design since 2016. And the 2019 model is no exception. It is the same simple and minimalistic design with the Apple logo located on the back. There is not much to talk about the design since it has been like that for quite a long time.

Sale
New Apple MacBook Pro (16-inch, 16GB RAM, 512GB Storage, 2.6GHz Intel Core i7) - Space Gray
  • Ninth-generation 6-Core Intel Core i7 Processor
  • Stunning 16-inch Retina Display with True Tone technology
  • Touch Bar and Touch ID
  • AMD Radeon Pro 5300M Graphics with GDDR6 memory
  • Ultrafast SSD

Last update on 2020-09-30 at 17:05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

However, the MacBook Pro is lighter and slimmer than ever. It weighs 4 lbs (1.81kg) and it’s almost half an inch thick. This makes it one of the slimmest and lightest laptops on the market.

The build quality of the MacBook Pro is excellent. An aluminium unibody design that has no flex and robust. There are no USB Type-A ports only Thunderbolt 3 ports which sucks. Because you need to carry a dock with you at all times.

Apple still maintains the butterfly keyboard design. They made some changes to it so that it won’t fail like the 2018 model. In addition to that, there is a keyboard replacement program. This somewhat tells you that the Butterfly keyboard is far from perfect.

Apple Macbook Pro Review

Now for upgradeability. The MacBook Pro is not upgradeable and difficult to repair. You will notice this quickly when you open it. The RAM, SSD and WLAN card is soldered onto the motherboard. This means you are stuck with whatever configuration you buy.

The battery is strongly glued onto the upper case making it hard to remove. And you have to remove a whole bunch of screws before you can remove the motherboard. The keyboard deck is also fixed onto the top part of the case.

In short, when your MacBook Pro gets damaged. You have to send it back to Apple for repairs or a replacement. And depending on the situation it can be expensive. In short, the MacBook Pro is non-upgradeable and difficult to repair.

Overall, the MacBook Pro has a better build quality than the Alienware. But, loses when it comes to upgradeability and repairs. Because even though the Alienware has soldered RAM and WLAN card you can still upgrade the SSD. Also, taking the Alienware apart is easy to do compared to the MacBook Pro.

For the design, it is subjective. The Alienware is beautiful but it has that gaming look. The Apple MacBook Pro, on the other hand, is simple and minimalistic. So for the better-looking one, it all depends on your taste.

Display

The Dell Alienware has a high-quality panel with slim bezels. The Alienware M15 comes with a 15.6-inch display and the M17 has a 17.3-inch display. For resolution, you have the option to choose between a Full HD IPS (1920 x 1080) or 4K (3840 x 2160) OLED display.

The Full HD is sharp, has decent viewing angles and average brightness. The 4K OLED display has a very high colour accuracy, sharpness and brightness. The displays also come with a 60Hz, 144Hz and 240Hz refresh rate i.e. for the Full HD.

apple macbook pro
Apple Macbook Pro

The 4K OLED has a 60Hz refresh rate. If you game a lot, you will know that the higher the refresh rate the smoother the gameplay. Because high refresh rates reduce visual distortions (screen tearing, stuttering and ghosting).

The MacBook Pro has options for a 13 inch and 15-inch display. Both are great and have high colour accuracy. They are also bright enough to be used outdoors. However, MacBooks make use of glossy displays so in bright light or sunlight, there will be reflections on the display.

The Retina display resolution is still maintained. It has a native resolution of 2560 x 1600 for 13-inch and 2880 x 1800 for 15-inch. Overall, MacBook Pro displays haven’t changed. If you are familiar with MacBook Pros. You know how the display is like.

alienware m15
Alienware M15 R2

Now for the most important part of the displays. If you game a lot. You will benefit from the Alienware’s high refresh rate display. The MacBook Pro has a 60Hz display and it is not suitable for fast-paced games because there will be a lot of visual distortions.

The Alienware also beats the MacBook Pro in colour accuracy. It is higher than it and therefore more suited for work that requires a lot of colour accuracy.

Where the MacBook Pro beats the Alienware is the brightness and viewing angles. It is brighter and has better viewing angles than the Alienware.

That is assuming, you choose the Full HD display over the 4K OLED. If you go with the 4K OLED, it is going to blow away the MacBook Pro’s display. It is sharper, brighter and far more accurate when it comes to colours. But, at the cost of having a 60Hz refresh rate.

Thermals

Slim and lightweight laptops are always going to run hot and thermal throttle no matter what. And the Alienware and MacBook Pro is no exception. However, the Alienware has clear advantages because you can apply the thermal paste and undervolt it to get better temperatures.

The MacBook Pro, on the other hand, applying thermal paste is the only solution. Because Apple blocks out the feature of it being undervolted. Disabling Intel Turbo boost is a good alternative.

Now to explain why these two laptops get hot i.e. aside from it being slim and lightweight.

First, Alienware.

The Alienware has a flipped motherboard. And that means the CPU and GPU are going to face the keyboard deck. Sadly, there aren’t enough vents for the heat to escape because of the keyboard. The underside also doesn’t have enough vents.

alienware m15 teardown
Alienware m15 Teardown Credit Dave2D

This results in a poorly ventilated laptop chassis that can reach high temperatures quickly. When it comes to the rear vents. The fans are no way close to it. Instead, it is heat pipes that are next to it. And so the fans are not able to push hot air out of the chassis efficiently.

There is a reason why air condition fans are located close to the opening.

Talking about heat pipes, there are four in total: two shared by the CPU and GPU at the same time each one has its own.

Now it becomes easy to see why the Alienware gets hot (90 degrees Celsius and above) quickly. Most gaming laptops have more than four heat pipes. The only thing that was done right is the size of the heat plates.

The MacBook Pro is a hot laptop, hotter than the Alienware. And it thermal throttles, all the time because the temperatures are also above 90 degrees Celsius. And here’s why? First of all, the MacBook Pro has thin vents. So thin it is difficult to see them.

This makes it difficult for hot air to be expelled and cool air to be drawn in. Moreover, it has only rear vents. So when you put in powerful components in a poorly ventilated slim chassis. You get a blazing device.

Ever been in a room full of people that has one small window and a fan? It gets hot quickly. The same thing that happens to the MacBook Pro. Even gaming laptops that have a lot of vents get hot.

Opening the MacBook Pro will expose another reason why it thermal and power throttles so badly. One heat pipe is shared by the powerful CPU and GPU which is cooled by two small fans at the end. And it is not able to dissipate heat quickly.

macbook pro teardown
Apple MacBook Pro Teardown

To be honest, the whole cooling system is a mess. This thing under heavy loads will get hot quickly and slowly destroy itself. It also won’t be able to sustain high boost clocks for long periods. It will drop to base clocks and it will still run hot.

In a MacBook Pro, you have powerful components, a single thin vent, not enough heat pipes, small fans and the inability to undervolt. This laptop will, by all means, thermal throttle like crazy.

All in all, Alienware wins this round. Because you can apply the thermal paste and undervolt it to bring it to appreciable temperatures. Unfortunately, with the MacBook Pro, you can only apply the thermal paste and it won’t even do a thing. Because the cooling system is not able to get rid of heat properly.

Alienware wins this round.

Performance

No matter how powerful the components in a slim and light laptop. The performance is going to be affected by temperature. Both are powerful laptops. But, power means nothing if they are not properly cooled.

The Alienware is a gaming laptop and a powerful one too. For the specs, you can choose between a Intel Core i5/i7/i9, 8/16/32GB RAM and a GTX 1660 Ti/RTX 2060/2070 Max-Q/2080 Max-Q.

Powerful components that will give you high FPS on AAA title games no matter the settings. If you do some video or multimedia editing. It will be enough to handle it. However, best to go with Intel Core i7 and 16GB RAM or above if you are in that line of work. The storage devices are also fast. PCI-e M.2 that have high read and write speeds.

The Apple MacBook Pro is also powerful but it is limited by its high temperatures. It won’t be able to sustain high clock speeds for long periods. Unless Apple fixes this. You won’t be able to take advantage of the powerful components. Which is a waste of money since you bought it because of its power.

For the specs, you have a Intel Core i5/i7/i9, 8GB/16GB/32GB RAM, AMD Radeon Pro Graphics (15 inch only) and up to 4TB of storage options. If you are into gaming. Better skip, the MacBook Pro because they are not meant for games. Only a select few games will run well on it.

The rest will be unplayable or run on low FPS even though you have a powerful processor and graphics cards. Macs are just not great for gaming. Where the MacBook Pro shines is the multimedia work and rendering.

A workstation that you can use to use edit your multimedia work and render AutoCAD, SolidWorks, etc. The AMD Radeon Pro is a workstation graphics and will do a much better job at rendering than a consumer graphics card.

Overall, the Alienware M15 beats the MacBook Pro in real-world performance and gaming because of its better cooling system. However, the MacBook Pro comes out on top if you are rendering a lot. The only thing that stops it from achieving its full potential is the cooling system.

Battery Life

This is where the MacBook Pro shines – battery life. It can last 9-10 hours under consistent use which is impressive. Because it has powerful components which normally take a toll on battery life.

The Alienware also isn’t that bad for a gaming laptop. It’s able to last 4-5 hours under normal use. Most gaming laptops last 2-3 hours.

However, the Apple MacBook Pro is the clear winner in this.

Is Alienware Better Than MacBook Pro – Which One To Get?

To be honest, it is not a difficult choice. Because both cater to different things. The Alienware is a gaming laptop and so it’s great at handling demanding games. You can still use it for other things though.

The MacBook Pro is the go-to workstation for multimedia work e.g. Final Cut and business. But, not so great for gaming. So it all depends on what you are looking for.

If you find yourself gaming a lot. Then the Alienware M15 is the right machine. But, if you edit a lot of photos, videos, rendering, etc. The MacBook Pro will be the better option.

This is not to say the Alienware can’t do the same thing. But, there are somethings the Apple MacBook Pro will do better than the Alienware M15 and vice versa.

All you have to do is see which one cater to your needs best. And you are good to go.

Alienware M15/17

Sale
New Alienware m15 15.6 inch FHD Gaming Laptop (Lunar Light) Intel Core i7-10750H 10th Gen, 16GB DDR4 RAM, 1TB SSD, Nvidia Geforce RTX 2070 Super 8GB GDDR6, Windows 10 Home (AWm15-7418WHT-PUS)
  • High-end materials like magnesium alloy, copper and steel provide a premium, lightweight and performance-driven gaming experience with...
  • Our fastest panel yet offers 300Hz 300nits 3ms Full HD for smooth, high-speed motion graphics
  • Alienware Cryo-Tech optimizes component cooling, which maximizes overall performance and keeps your laptop cool to the touch
  • FHD display with 3ms response time, 100,000:1 contrast ratio, 60Hz refresh rate and 300-nit brightness for pulse-racing gameplay
  • At just 4.65lb and under 20.5mm, the new Alienware m15 is the thinnest laptop in Alienware history—even lighter and leaner than our...

Last update on 2020-09-30 at 20:35 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Apple MacBook Pro

Sale
New Apple MacBook Pro (16-inch, 16GB RAM, 512GB Storage, 2.6GHz Intel Core i7) - Space Gray
  • Ninth-generation 6-Core Intel Core i7 Processor
  • Stunning 16-inch Retina Display with True Tone technology
  • Touch Bar and Touch ID
  • AMD Radeon Pro 5300M Graphics with GDDR6 memory
  • Ultrafast SSD

Last update on 2020-09-30 at 17:05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Sale
New Apple MacBook Pro (13-inch, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD Storage, Magic Keyboard) - Space Gray
  • Tenth-generation quad-core Intel Core i5 processor
  • Brilliant Retina display with True Tone technology
  • Backlit Magic Keyboard
  • Touch Bar and Touch ID
  • Intel Iris Plus Graphics

Last update on 2020-09-30 at 20:55 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave A Reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Sponsored

Related Stories